
And we have a new Supreme!
"Ladies and gentleman," Myrtle said, "I give you Cordelia Goode, your new Supreme Commander and Galactic Overlord."Then Cordelia's scar tissue leapt off her face and revealed its true identity as a sentient alien being, sent to watch over the witches by their Empress, Connie Britton, who would have come herself but just couldn't get out of the house. Everyone was beamed directly into season four except for Stevie Nicks, who was too busy twirling to notice.
Well... that could have happened.
I really liked this episode. It had a clear purpose, measurable stakes, three True Deaths(!), and Sarah Paulson looking goddamn radiant. The Seven Wonders trials were a lot of fun, particularly when the ladies began enjoying themselves. Whether it was Zoe and Madison facing off through Kyle or a spirited game of transmutation-tag, AHS reminded us why anyone would even want to be a witch. Although the trials didn't work out so well for Misty or Madison, Cordelia's last-minute steal felt satisfying, particularly in the months afterward, when she showed herself as a natural leader.
Those closing moments - with Cordelia and her council greeting a new generation of witches - felt like something that, on a regular, non-anthology show, would be setting up for a game-changing second season. A season that would probably be stronger, because it would have a clear goal - rebuild the coven - and far fewer characters to muddy up the plot. I feel ungrateful dissing Delphine, Marie, and Fiona, because I should just shut up and appreciate the fact that Kathy Bates, Angela Bassett, and Jessica Lange have deigned to entertain me for the past thirteen weeks. But this season of AHS has been my least favorite, largely because these ladies, even played by such legendary actresses, didn't contribute much to the story. Delphine could have stayed buried all season and literally nothing in the coven would have changed. Marie was a threat for what, three episodes? Before she joined up against the real threat, the witch hunters, who turned out to be so squashable, I wonder why the witches didn't stamp them out in 1850?
As for Fiona... oh, Fiona. In the season's first episode, we see that the coven is in decline. And why is that? Because Fiona is sucking away its lifeblood, and has been for years. If the (very) general goal of the season has been to protect and restore the coven, then the real villain wasn't Hank's dad - it was its own Supreme. Yet the witches didn't battle her until the very end, and I can't quite bring myself to believe that this was a measured choice.
But enough whining. Wasn't it cool when Cordelia lifted the piano?!
Cordelia

Some people just need a little push. With Myrtle's encouragement, Cordelia breezed through the Supreme trials, made an as-good-as-it's-gonna-get peace with her awful mom, and brought the coven into modern times. It's very True Blood - what happens when witches come out of the coffin coven?
Apparently the fake news producers didn't think the public would see witchcraft as that that big a deal, though, because they put an "UP NEXT: LIZA MINELLI TALKS ABOUT HER HIP" chyron below Cordy's head during her interview. You know what I'd put there? A massive flashing graphic that says "HOLY SHIT YOU GUYS, MAGIC IS REAL!!!!"
Fiona

Oh look, Fiona's alive. She pulled off her fake death in exactly the way we'd assumed. Yawn. But in the end, she accepts the end, croaking out a platitude for Delia in her Cryptkeeper skullcap and moving on to that not-very-big knotty pine cabin in the sky. This show has a very existential view of hell - no fire, no torture. Just a Groundhog Day situation with people we already know.
Misty

On that note, I am highly displeased that Misty is stuck in hell. I, too, would freak out at the prospect of an endless biology lab. Why does this Wonder come so early in the testing, anyway? She couldn't try talking to rocks first? Oh, Misty. In this show's pretend season two, I've decided that that Cordelia gets you out.
Myrtle

I really thought that Myrtle would turn out to be secretly evil. And I guess she was, with all the eyeball-scooping, but if we played by that metric the whole coven should be in jail. Instead, Myrtle gets as close as she ever will to fulfill her early wish to be the Supreme, by fulfilling the Supreme’s most important duty – finding the next one. With that under her belt, it’s time to go: back up in flames, with a truly perfect last word.
Zoe & Madison


The Seven Wonders
Extra Credit
The girls preparing for the trials as Stevie danced through the mansion in a top hat.
- Misty, obviously, prepared for the trials by twirling.
- Myrtle's oh-so-fancy last supper, and the beautifully shot tableau.
- Queenie's Cordelia-controlled aerobicising.
- Fiona's primal scream upon realizing that the Axeman's cabin is her personal hell: "KNOTTY PIIIIIINNNEEE>!>!>!>????!!!!!"
Demerits
- MISTY DIED. FOR REAL. NOT OK.